Can the first Estonian CIO help India become the next digital society?

May 2019

by Federico Plantera

From one million to one billion – that’s the target, at least in demographic terms. But Taavi Kotka, the former CIO of the Government of Estonia, has never looked like someone who’s scared of challenges. With his Proud Engineers and the support of India’s richest man, Mukesh Ambani, Kotka is now consulting, coaching and cooperating with Reliance Industries to make India the next digital poster country of Asia.

Kotka does not really need introductions. After twelve years as the head of Estonian company Nortal, he then held the post of Chief Information Officer of the Estonian government from 2013 until 2017. As the founder of digital transformation consultancy Proud Engineers, he’s helping Mukesh Ambani turn India into a digital society. Who better than him, then?

Ambani, #13 among Billionaires 2019 according to Forbes and one of Time’s Titans2019, is the Chairman and Managing Director of Reliance Industries – India’s corporate giant, from oil refining to telecommunications. He’s also an e-resident of Estonia. After setting up the research centre Jio Estonia, with Kotka as its CEO, Ambani is now deploying his expertise to understand what it takes to walk the path of digitalisation.

We spoke to Taavi Kotka to find out what’s in the air, and to hear from his voice if and how India can make it. Don’t be surprised if you see that you already know the answer – it’s “yes”.

One year of activity and a strong bet on human capital. How does the success story of Estonia reflect in the projects of Jio Estonia and Proud Engineers?

Our team consists of people from different disciplines. Their expertise has been gathered through private and public sector experience during twenty years of digital revolution in Estonia. We are not the company that implements X-Road or the Land Registry. We are more interested in projects where digital change can have a significant impact. Then, if we need additional resources or specific solutions, we will find the right people or companies from the Estonian market.

What are the most salient challenges that countries and organizations face with digitalisation today? Are they that different between each other in this, or there are points of contact?

The Western hemisphere doesn’t feel the pain to move on with their digital reforms, except for the private sector. But it is crucial for a digital society that the foundation, and the reforms, are delivered together by both private and public sectors. For example, solving the question “Who is behind the device?”, or accepting electronic signature widely, or having a digital-only mindset etc.

Countries and large companies understanding the value of combining information from totally different datasets advance rapidly compared to others. Look, for example, at what China is already capable of doing.

Do you think there is a recipe, a paradigmatic path to digitalisation?

Yes, absolutely sure. We have even written an IKEA-like manual for that purpose: “126 steps to creating a digital society”.

You have started working with Mukesh Ambani, India’s richest man. Could India become the next, and surely one of the most populous, digital nation? 

India is able to do radical reforms, if needed. The way they built the foundation for a digital society was remarkable. They issued unique identifiers to more than one billion people, ready to use in both the private and public sectors. This was something that the UK, the US, Germany, Australia etc have not been able to achieve.

In this sense, India has advanced rapidly. The pace is now slightly slower, as the supreme court has also asked to put privacy laws in place before accelerating again. The problem is that the Western world talks a lot about similar reforms, but we cannot see any true action happening.

From 1 million people in Estonia to more than 1 billion in India. What difference does that make with regards to such process?

In the digital world, countries have the same size. Look at internet banking in different countries: they are about 90% the same everywhere. The scale is the difference, but Estonians have always been able to deliver solutions for global markets. We are not that concerned about this – what is different is the maturity of society.

In India, many processes are still on paper, electronic signature and digital authentication are not widely used. But at the same time, just to mention one example, financial transactions are happening way faster in India than in Europe.

What is your role in the cooperation with Ambani? In which way your team and skills will operate in India?

Mr. Ambani has a very clear vision of a digital India. To support that, he wanted to create a research and knowledge centre in Estonia to help digital India become a reality. And to see how Reliance Industries as a group of companies, including telecommunications, can support this journey. The role of our team is to design and offer solutions, but also coach and support teams in India.

Other big companies advise on digital development. To make the difference, what do Jio Estonia and Proud Engineers stand out and stand up for?

All our engineers have real-life experience with those kinds of reforms. We’ve been put to test in the midst of the action, so we know what pain it takes to make change happen. We also know what might be the failures and fallbacks before achieving success. And mind you, this type of experience doesn’t only include technology, but also how society should be motivated.

Resource: e-estonia

The Estonian vision for new models of smart city

May 2019

by Federico Plantera

Arguably, smart cities represent the meeting point between three of the main themes we will discuss the most in the near future – digital transformation, environmental issues, economic performance. As urbanization increases, living standards and sustainability progressively change from simple areas of discussion to calls for action. After raising awareness, we must now investigate all possible solutions that can have an impact on a changing world.

From social matters to the climate emergency, research into the development of adaptive models of smart cities can provide a vision for the future. For a future spanning beyond the next five or seven years, conceptualizing long-term plans to make urban agglomerations more inclusive, efficient, and attentive towards environmental issues. We saw how Tallinn already made a move towards the development of its own smart city model. Further projects in Tartu, and the ambitious Finest Twins plan for the Tallinn-Helsinki area, make Estonia one of the urban and social laboratories of Europe most committed to change.

Cross-border sustainability between Tallinn and Helsinki

It is not a mystery that Estonia and Finland share ties that go well beyond geography, history, and culture. Now, Tallinn and Helsinki are building a model of smart and sustainable twin cities to establish a paradigm for development also at a European level.

The project is already more than just an idea. Awarded a 32 million euros grant co-funded by the European Union and the Government of Estonia, Finest Twins will create a Centre of Excellence (CoE) for Smart and Sustainable Cities to deepen research and development into new models of municipal smart governance. The project was initiated by Ralf-Martin Soe, Research Fellow at the Department of Innovation Governance of TalTech. Aalto University (Finland), Forum Virium Helsinki, and the Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications figure as partners.

Tallinn and Helsinki are commonly referred to as “Talsinki” not by chance. Finest Twins aims to create user-driven, “cross-border-by-default” smart city solutions directed at improving mobility, energy efficiency, and the built environment. Digital governance and urban analytics offer countless opportunities. Finest Twins relies on ICT to close gaps in regional cohesion and economic development through digitalisation, spill-over effects, and social entrepreneurship.

“Estonia has a very strong international reputation in the field of digital governance. With this project, we would like to add another layer to the story through smart city development”, says the initiator of the project, Ralf-Martin Soe.

Finest Twins will run until 2026, merging the Finnish expertise and resources for research with Estonia’s knowledge in implementing high-tech solutions. Cross-border smart city governance is possible. In this way, Tallinn and Helsinki are pursuing the unique chance of setting a virtuous example for the rest of Europe.

Energy efficiency in Tartu – from Soviet blocks of flats to smart city grids

Meanwhile, the city of Tartu is taking a major step towards increased energy efficiency. With the European project SmartEnCity, municipal agencies are contributing to renovate old Soviet blocks of flats (Khrushchyovka). The target is to decrease their current, high levels of energy consumption. The buildings will connect to the almost 100% renewables-powered city district heating system. Smart home solutions will monitor the indoor climate and consumption.

740 apartments in 19 buildings constitute, for now, the core of the project. Lauri Sokk, Head of Smart City Tartu, explains how needs brought up by citizens themselves drive such development.

“We avoid adopting innovative smart city technologies to look cool. In this case, we actually need them. We faced a really big problem – the centre of Tartu was filled with energy-consuming, costly, old Soviet buildings”, Sokk explains.

Citizens’ involvement in the improvement of living standards has always been very present in Tartu. The city is one of the first in the world to adopt participatory budgeting. “Citizens are the core and the most important thing for our smart city. That’s why most of the important decisions affecting them are always open to the public for discussion”, Sokk says. With the undergoing building renovations, Tartu is moving in the direction of cost efficiency and energy sustainability.

Though Estonia already has a competitive edge in moving towards smart city models, there’s still a lot to do. “Estonian public services are 99% digitalized, and this is great. However, most cities here are unable to provide some of these services at a municipal level. We must work on making local services as effective and predictive as state services are. Our vision for a smarter city is based on considering also such needs of citizens”, Sokk concludes.

Resource: e-estonia

President’s interview with Etonian Public Broadcaster – Eesti Rahvusringhääling

05/22/2019

As a part of her official visit in Talin President Salome Zourabichvili spoke to Estonian Public Broadcaster – Eesti Rahvusringhääling

TV: You have frozen conflicts with Russia…
Mrs. President: It’s not a frozen conflict, they’re occupied territories. Frozen conflicts, it was before. As to the occupied territories, yes it’s a major problem, it’s more than a problem, it’s an everyday tragedy, not only for the population that lives on our side of the occupying line and not only for the population that lives on the other side of the occupying line, but for the 300.000 refugees that we have on the Georgian side of the occupying line and for the authorities, because it’s every day that we have to deal with somebody being taken hostage on the occupying line, that we don’t know when and how that person will be returned, moving that occupying line, which is very stressful, and all kinds of daily provocations that we have.
But despite that, that has not interfered with our intention toward the European Union, that has not changed our direction, and if that was the objective, as it probably was the objective of Russia, Russia has missed the point. We are maybe even more determined, because we know that we don’t have any other perspective or alternative and, after all, we also have very good examples in Europe that having an occupied territory does not deter from a European future. Look at Germany…
 
TV: What would you say to Mr. Putin?
Mrs. President: Well, what would Mr. Putin say to me? That’s the question. He has to make the first move and that’s the problem of the relations of all European partners with Russia. Russia is misbehaving as an international community member, is not respecting anything, it’s not only towards Georgia, it’s in general. So what type of dialogue do you have in these conditions? I can have a dialogue with Mr. Putin that would be just reminding him that he has violated all the commitments.
 
TV:  What about Saakashvili’s future?
Mrs. President: Please keep him somewhere else, whoever wants. I think it’s not an issue anymore in Georgian politics, his time has gone and he has not managed to reinvent himself.
 
TV: Absolutely no relations with Mr. Saakashvili whatsoever?
Mrs. President: No
 
TV: Doesn’t it make it a bit, let’s say awkward, when you are President right now and, let’s say in ten years’ time, the regime changes and they will try to put you on court and blame you about something?
Mrs. President: Certainly not, because I’ve not done any of the things that Saakashvili has done, so I have no single fear of anything of that kind. You have to know how to behave when you are in a position of power and if you go overboard, then you know also what the consequences are. Again, I don’t think it’s an actual problem for either Georgia or Mr. Saakashvili and I think that Ukraine is maybe waiting for him.
 
TV:  Your last President started an AirBnB as I understood. It was a big news. Will you be also, after the presidency, doing something like this, or what is your future, what do you think?
Mrs. President:  Maybe I’ll be writing something again, it’s a very interesting experience. I’ve never been in business so AirBnB is not my future. Maybe there should be a pension for retirement. On the other side, it’s very democratic that the former President is now receiving hosts in his house.
 
TV:  If you have that kind of high-level representative doing something like this and the message goes that you don’t have a pension system for the President. Why?
Mrs. President:  There is for the Parliament, there is not for the president. Why? I don’t know. That’s the way it was, because previously, until Saakashvili (included), Presidents were making so much money that they didn’t need pensions and I think that’s also changed. It shows the changes that the country has gone through, that the former President is actually giving lectures in the Public Affairs Institute. So probably there should be a pension, except I’m not going to propose it, because then everybody will say that she is proposing it for herself

Resourse: ERR

President of Georgia visited the e-Estonia Briefing Centre

May 2019

On Friday, May 17th we had the pleasure to host President of Georgia, Salome Zourabichvili at the e-Estonia Briefing Centre.

President Zourabichvili was welcomed by Managing Director of the Briefing Centre, Liina Maria Lepik. After that she and her accompanying delegation were given a presentation by Anett Numa, presenter at the Briefing Centre.

The presentation gave an introduction to the Estonian digital society and covered some of the key e-governance solutions that Estonia relies on. There was also discussion on what similar services are already implemented in Georgia and which areas could benefit from cooperation. The delegation was very interested in the economic impact of e-residency, e-prescription and its cross-border applications and the X-road.

Resourse: e-estonia